What has every Harry
Potter fan been waiting for since the series ended? Another Harry
Potter book. And with Harry Potter and The Cursed Child, we got our
wish... sort of.
The 8th
Harry Potter book is not a novel, it is the script for a play. I know
that this bothered a lot of people quite a bit, but being someone who
has been in theatre, the script-style of the book didn't really
bother me. However, I did have a few complaints.
To start, I found
the dialogue very choppy and unnatural. One thing I love about
scripts is the way dialogue just flows back and forth from person to
person, and I think that this script really lacked in that. Maybe I
would have a different opinion if I saw it live, but from a reader's
point of view, it just didn't work for me.
Also, these
characters didn't feel like the ones I grew up reading about. The
entire time, it felt like I was reading about different characters
with the same names as the characters I knew and loved. These
grown-up versions of the characters lacked depth. I mean, where were
their personalities? I think that had the characters been more
fleshed out, the dialogue would have been a lot more natural.
One thing I did
like was that while the story took off slowly, it picked up in the
middle, and there were a few good unexpected twists and turns in the
plot. A downfall was that while the plot was neat, it was the only
plot. This story seriously lacked in subplots, and while I understand
that a play can't have as many subplots as a novel, there still could
have been one or two subplots added to make the story more
interesting.
There were a few
parts of this story that I really enjoyed. One of these was Draco
Malfoy's part. His character was one that I actually connected to and
felt emotion from. Another little bit of the story that I liked was
Ron's line, “Blimey! There are two of them!” in reference to both
Scorpius and Hermione answering a question Albus asks about history.
This remark could easily be overlooked, but it connects to one of the
earlier Harry Potter books, where Ron says that Hermione is the only
one to read A History of Magic. I really liked this little connection
to the original series.
Overall, it wasn't
awful. I enjoyed reading another Harry Potter book, although it
didn't quite live up to my expectations. I gave this book 3 out of 5stars on Goodreads. Tell me in the comments below what you thought of
the book!
No comments:
Post a Comment